Explore Bay Heights

Often described as one of Miami's best-kept secrets, Bay Heights is a walled residential oasis offering 56 luxury homes along seven winding tree-lined streets at the northern edge of Coconut Grove.

Welcome to Bay Heights, a discreet, high-demand neighborhood with a limited collection of spacious mid-century modern and contemporary residences, many of which sit on larger lots compared to those in Central and South Coconut Grove, that has built a reputation on its unique blend of privacy, security, and convenience, enhanced by the graceful presence of Coconut Grove's iconic peacocks.

Bay Heights spans an estimated 25 to 30 acres just east of US-1 and tucked between Coconut Grove to the south and Coral Gables to the west, with Brickell and Downtown Miami only minutes to the northeast.

It is home to approximately 1,023 residents as of the latest US Census.

"Miami's Secret Walled Community" is the unofficial moniker of Bay Heights, and rightfully so, as it's positioned within the deepest northern edges of Coconut Grove that even longtime Miamians barely know exists.

Yet, it does, and it deserves all the hype coming after everyone has read our blog!

You see, despite its exclusive and extremely private location, Bay Heights is surprisingly pretty accessible from all directions.

It's positioned in one of Miami's most sought-after locales, Coconut Grove, and a hop from Coral Gables, Little Havana, Brickell, Downtown Miami, South Miami, and the exclusive communities of Cocoplum, Tahiti Beach, Cloisters on the Bay, and... need we go on?

Bay Heights has everything you desire in a neighborhood - privacy, 24/7 security, and an unbeatable location that connects you to the rest and the BEST of Miami, starting with its green spaces.

With waterfront parks and shaded trails surrounding the area, Bay Heights is never far from the beauty of South Florida.

You have Alice Wainwright Park offering bayfront paths and open lawns framed by skyline views, and David T. Kennedy Park adding more expansive open spaces, walking paths, and the Coconut Grove Dog Park for four-legged outings. 

A little farther south takes you to Peacock Park, its waterfront setting, and community events, while Silver Bluff Park provides you with a quieter, neighborhood-friendly alternative.

Then, in between, small tot lots and pocket parks are scattered throughout nearby streets.

For errands or casual browsing, you're minutes from some of Magic City's top shopping destinations, with CocoWalk leading the show, followed by Mary Brickell Village and Brickell City Centre in close second.

And if that's not enough, the Shops at Merrick Park provides an open-air mix of luxury brands and polished dining in the west.

Culture and history are just as accessible, allowing residents to curate an adventure beyond the usual routes and routines.

For one, Vizcaya Museum & Gardens, just outside Bay Heights' official boundaries, offers formal gardens and historic architecture set along the bay, while The Barnacle Historic State Park preserves Miami's oldest home within a quiet waterfront setting.

The National Shrine of Our Lady of Charity adds cultural and spiritual significance rooted in the city's Cuban heritage, and nearby viewpoints along the bay promise some of Miami's most recognizable skyline views.

Need a breather from the city's bustle? Hobie Island Beach Park opens the door to casual shoreline escapes.

Marinas are also peppered throughout the area, with Dinner Key, one of Miami's most established marinas, and Bayshore Landing offering access to Biscayne Bay, a quick drive away, for those who find boating an occasional indulgence.

No matter what kind of day you're planning — outdoorsy, indulgent, low-key, or last-minute — it's probably closer to Bay Heights than you think.

Now that we've let you in on what's around Bay Heights, we're 100% certain you're curious about what's INSIDE, so let's take a look, shall we?

Defined by its low-density layout, mature landscaping, and a strong sense of residential continuity, Bay Heights offers a lifestyle rooted in privacy, space, and convenience. 

It's a neighborhood that revolves around design, location, and livability, with quiet streets that coexist just minutes from some of Miami's busiest corners.

Within, you'll find 56 single-family homes with floor plans that favor openness and functionality, many outfitted with mid-century modern design, while others showcase contemporary rebuilds that make the most of oversized lots and interiors that often open seamlessly to private gardens, resort-style pools, and outdoor entertaining areas.

Around-the-clock security patrols and limited through-traffic reinforce Bay Heights' privacy and exclusivity despite not having actual gates.

Given these luxurious features, its size, and stability, it's no surprise that Bay Heights real estate rarely flies under the radar.

Properties currently for sale range from the low $2 million to over $8 million, with pricing reflecting both scarcity and demand.

On a per-square-foot basis, asking prices average just over $1,050, with closed sales trending higher — a signal of continued strength among buyers who prioritize location and long-term value.

Rental opportunities are just as limited, but equally telling.

Homes available for lease typically command monthly rates between the mid-$16,000s and low-$20,000s, appealing to residents seeking short-term flexibility without compromising on space, privacy, or lifestyle.

Whether buying or renting, Bay Heights attracts those who prefer established neighborhoods with room to settle, just moments from essentials such as malls, grocery stores, schools like Coconut Grove Elementary, Ransom Everglades, and Carrollton School of the Sacred Heart, and premium healthcare from HCA Florida Mercy Hospital and Baptist Health Doctors Hospital.

Indeed, choosing a community to live in means finding a version of Miami that fits perfectly.

And if you're among those who seek understated luxury and quality of life over bustling city life, the Bay Heights lifestyle is made for you.

Take a chance on a hidden oasis that shields you from the chaos of the city yet keeps you close to all its glory.

Bay Heights offers that rare in-between — privacy, exclusivity, and connection to the BEST of Miami.

And that, really, is the draw.

No bold promises. No big pitch.

Just a place that makes sense the longer you spend around it.

Have a look, plan a stroll, and let Bay Heights show you the rest.

Bay Heights Homes for Sale 

AMIT BHUTA

COMPASS

LICENSED REAL ESTATE AGENT

(305) 439-3031  MOBILE

[email protected]

Who are we?

We are the ALL IN Miami Group out of Miami. 

We are Colombian, Filipino, Cuban, German, Japanese, French, Indian, Irish, Syrian, and American. 

We are Christian, Hindu, and Jewish. 

We are many, but we are one.

We sell luxury homes in Miami, Florida. 

Although some of our clients are celebrities, athletes, and people you read about online, we also help young adults find their first place to rent when they are ready to live on their own. 

First-time buyers? 

All the time!

No matter what your situation or price range is, we feel truly blessed and honored to play such a big part in your life.