Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?

Top 5 Places to Get Dessert in Fisher Island

Amit Bhuta

I use non-traditional marketing to inspire the most motivated buyers to pay the max for Miami luxury homes...

I use non-traditional marketing to inspire the most motivated buyers to pay the max for Miami luxury homes...

Aug 12 8 minutes read

Hailed as the country's wealthiest zip code, Fisher Island is the perfect example of an ultra-private island PARADISE.

Aside from its expensive real estate and world-class amenities, the elite luxury oasis is sought-after for its exclusivity and peaceful setting on the sparkling blue waters of beautiful Biscayne Bay, despite being only MINUTES from the mainland. 

And when I say PRIVATE and EXCLUSIVE, I mean only residents and their guests can go in and out of the island through an exclusive ferry or private boats and helicopters!

So, if you get the chance to get a glimpse of Fisher Island, it's inevitable to feel like you have to experience everything 'coz you don't know if there'll be a "next time" unless you're filthy rich like the rest of the folks on the island! 

Of course, one of the top ways to get to know a foreign destination is through its food, particularly the 'sweet' station, if you know what I mean!

Although dining and pretty much everything is limited on Fisher Island (as it's not exactly a tourist destination), the neighborhood is only three miles from Miami shores and a stone's throw from the sophisticated glamour of South Beach, so you won't feel like you're missing out!

That said, let me hook you up with the best desserts around Fisher Island-- and across it-- to satisfy that dessert craving!

Here are the top 5 dessert places you can try while you're here (in no particular order).

Fisher Island Beach Club Restaurant

15211 Fisher Island Dr, Miami Beach, FL 33109

✅ Dine-in - ✅ Takeout - ✅ Outdoor Dining

If you don't feel like riding out on a ferry for a quick dessert, there are always a few options for dessert on Fisher Island, albeit not as cheap as the ones on the Mainland. 

One of the top options is Fisher Island Beach Club Restaurant, a go-to for residents and their guests for delicious food, drinks, and sweets on the island.

Airy and elegant white seaside pavilions provide shade and synergy to the stunning Beach Club. 

The outdoor venue serves breakfast and lunch and is famous for its relaxed atmosphere, featuring casual fare with a hint of Riviera chic. 

With the arrival of sunset over Biscayne Bay, members and guests can be found gathering at the Sunset Bar for pre-dinner cocktails and fresh, artfully plated sushi. 

Their menu also features a few desserts, including a Flourless Chocolate Cake (perfect for the health-conscious), Baked Alaska, ice cream in chef's signature flavors, assorted jumbo cookies, and more.

A good stopover on the island after a day of lounging at the beach!

Fisher Island Club's Porto Cervo Restaurant

40120 Fisher Island Dr, Miami, FL 33109

✅ Dine-in - ✅ Takeout - ✅ Outdoor Dining

Another option on the island is Porto Cervo Restaurant, which serves up a delightful Italian culinary experience on par with the distinguished elegance that only Fisher Island Club can offer. 

The restaurant is famous for serving crowd-pleasing dishes for discerning palates, and its menu and design reflect classic Italian and Mediterranean cuisine at its best. 

Enjoy authentic, artfully-plated dishes while overlooking the island's Main Marina. 

Porto Cervo represents the pure pleasure of savoring a meal down to the last delicious bite.

For dessert, guests can enjoy delicious Italian dessert classics like Tiramisu, Crème Brûlée, Mini Italian Donuts & Nutella, Tartufo al Cioccolato, and an array of gelato and sorbetto flavors.


1250 Ocean Dr, Miami Beach, FL 33139

✅ Dine-in - ✅ Takeout 

A family-run business focusing on artisan ice cream and desserts, Icy-N-Spicy is a South Beach dessert shop that combines the ice cream flavors of Europe and Asia, boasting phenomenal signature recipes of spicy ice cream concocted by their owner, Xiaoli Liu, and not far from departing the Fisher Island ferry back to South Beach.

It's so unique that Fisher Island folks are going ga-ga over the outrageous combination!

Yes, peeps, your eyes do not deceive you! 

They really are serving spicy ice cream! 

And not just any SPICY ice cream. 

We're talking about artisan ice cream flavors made using local fresh ingredients to ensure the best quality of desserts. 

Icy-N-Spicy also offers delicious specialty milkshakes, cupcakes, and even cotton candy! 

And to top it all off, the fun dessert shop is located at a colorful venue inside an art deco hotel. 

Talk about Instagram-worthy!

When you want a sugar rush but want it to look good for the 'gram, come out to Icy-N-Spicy! 

Their creations aren't just pretty; they taste delicious too! 

Rosetta Bakery

1666 Collins Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33139

✅ Takeout - ✅ Outdoor dining - ✅ Delivery - ✅ Dine-in

Another sensational dessert place in nearby South Beach is an Italian dessert bakery, Rosetta Bakery, which deserves all the accolades and praises for its intricate menu of classic Italian sweets and pastries.

Offering customers a cozy and homey space where they can choose foods directly from the display, interact on community tables, and experience the entire production processes thanks to a laboratory with a transparent window, Rosetta Bakery is a favorite among locals and tourists, especially after a long day out on the beach or to cap off a hearty meal. 

Here, you can order from a tempting array of baked goods and coffee, with options ranging from tarts and croissants to other delicious concoctions that will make your mouth water! 

Every item is made by hand and looks as gorgeous as it tastes! 

I won't be surprised if you come back every day-- even if it means going on a ferry back and forth!

Wet Dreams

214 Española Way Miami Beach, FL 33139

✅ Dine-in - ✅ Takeout - ✅ Delivery

Make your dessert fantasies into reality at Wet Dreams, a naughty novelty dessert shop that's a ferry ride away from Fisher Island in Miami Beach!

Boasting a unique dining experience designed to delight your senses while offering a playful and daring way to challenge common taboos, Wet Dream is a sweet spot for sweet-tooth looking for a more daring way to satisfy their dessert cravings. 

While technically their menu is all about the waffles and ice cream, Wet Dreams unconventionally present their products-- and well, let's say they're NOT for the conservative!

Enjoy eating delicious waffles and ice cream after a long day of exploring the vibrant neighborhoods of Miami Beach during your Fisher Island stay! 

You're bound for a memorable dessert experience, I can tell you that!

Selling Your Home? 

Get your home's value in seconds!

Get Home Value

Who are we?

We are the ALL IN Miami Group out of Miami. 

We are Honduran, Filipino, Puerto Rican, Cuban, German, Hispanic, Indian, Syrian, and American. 

We are Christian, Hindu, and Jewish. 

We are many, but we are one.

We sell luxury homes in Miami, Florida. 

Although some of our clients are celebrities, athletes, and people you read about online, we also help young adults find their first place to rent when they are ready to live on their own. 

First-time buyers? 

All the time!

No matter what your situation or price range is, we feel truly blessed and honored to play such a big part in your life.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies. More info